Is Solution For The Russian Federation-Ukraine War Most Efficient With Two, Three, Eleven, Or Sixty-Six? More Bodies Means Less Conversation And More Presentation.  Circumference Matters.

Is The Solution For The Russian Federation-Ukraine War Most Efficient With Two, Three, Eleven, Or Sixty-Six?

Thus Far, Two Chairs At The Table Not Viable.  Three Chairs At The Table Are Active.  Will Sixty-Six Chairs At The Table Make A Resolution More Likely? 

More Bodies Around A Table Means Less Conversation And More Presentation. 

Circumference Of The Table Matters.  Distance Matters. 

Expanding The Number Of People In The Room Expands The Number Of Subjects Discussed. 

Kushner-Witkoff Gaza Record Instructive To Consider Potential Outcomes For Ukraine 

No Head Of State Or Head Of Government Will Sign A Document To Guarantee A Member Of Their Armed Forces Will Be Permitted To Die Defending The Internationally-Recognized Territory Of Ukraine.  Any Document Will Have An Out And President Putin Will Know It So Not Fear It, But Will Negotiate Against It. 

A result of the gathering in Abu Dhabi, United Aab Emirates, with representatives of the government of Ukraine, government of the Russian Federation, and government of the United States; a bilateral gathering the following day in Moscow, Russian Federation, with representatives of the government of the Russian Federation and government of the United States; and then a multi-country gathering in Dublin, Ireland, was to expand the number of participants engaged to bring an end to the Russian Federation-Ukraine War (2014- ).  

Along with the exponential increase in the number of individuals invited to participate in the conversations, dialogues, discussions, engagements, and negotiations there is an expansion in the number of issues, matters, subjects, and topics to be addressed. 

The Russian Federation-Ukraine War commenced in 2014 and expanded in 2022.  To date, Vladimir Putin, President of the Russian Federation (2000-2008 and 2012-2030), has refused to meet with Volodymyr Zelensky, President of Ukraine (2019-2024; term extended due to imposition of martial law in 2022), for the purpose of negotiating a resolution.  

President Putin wants negotiations completed in advance of any meeting with President Zelensky.  Meaning, President Putin will meet with President Zelensky to sign a document, not negotiate the contents of a document. 

Both President Putin and President Zelensky have embraced a role for Donald Trump, President of the United States (2017-2021 and 2025-2029). 

Absent remains Xi Jinping, President of the People’s Republic of China (2013-2027), whose commercial, economic, financial, military, political, and societal support to the government of the Russian Federation remains the primary resource permitting a continuation of the Russian Federation-Ukraine War. 

Until the government of the People’s Republic of China joins the conversation, the most impactive support mechanism to the government of the Russian Federation remains available to delay cessation of the military component of the Russian Federation-Ukraine War. 

There should be two chairs at the table- Russian Federation and Ukraine.  There are three chairs at the table- Russian Federation, Ukraine, and United States.

The twenty-seven-country members of the Brussels, Belgium-based European Union (EU) and the thirty-two-country members of the Brussels, Belgium-based North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) now want chairs at the table.  While the EU and NATO have overlapping memberships, the portfolios for each entity are different and the decision-making processes are different.  

For EU and NATO to agree with terms to resolve the Russian Federation-Ukraine War, the governments in each of the combined fifty-nine member countries will need to relinquish sovereignty from their respective capitals to institutions located in Brussels, Belgium. 

The EU and NATO seem to want chairs at the table so they may convey to the government of the Russian Federation that issues relating to EU and NATO security architectures are not to be discussed with the government of the Russian Federation absent cessation of the military component of the Russian Federation-Ukraine War.  Then would not be easier to convey that message by not having seats at the table at this time? 

  • EU: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden. 

  • NATO: United States, United Kingdom, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Albania, Lithuania, Bulgaria, Montenegro, Croatia, Czech Republic, Poland, Estonia, Romania, Germany, Slovakia, Greece, Slovenia, Sweden, Hungary, Spain, Turkiye, Latvia, North Macedonia.  

So, two chairs became three chairs and three chairs will become eleven chairs with the addition of National Security Advisors (NSAs) from the governments of Germany, France, Italy, Poland, and United Kingdom (not a member of the EU, but a founding member of the Coalition of the Willing), a representative of NATO, a representative of the European Commission (EC), and a representative of the European Council (EC).  

The Coalition of the Willing (EU+) will not have a mandate because impossible to craft a mandate to account for changes in real time to the realities on the ground- or at the table.  There is no viable pathway from complicated to nimble. 

  • “European Commission is the executive body of the EU.  Its main roles include: proposing new laws and policies; monitoring their implementation; managing the EU budget.  The Commission also ensures that EU policies and laws are correctly applied across Member States, negotiates international agreements on behalf of the EU, and allocates funding.  Additionally, it represents the interests of the EU on the global stage, ensuring a coordinated approach among EU countries.”  

  • “European Council is the EU institution that defines the general political direction and priorities of the EU.  The members of the European Council are the heads of state or government of the 27 EU member states, the European Council President and the President of the European Commission.” 

Noticeably, absent is Kaja Kallas, High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy.  Thus far, the delegations from the government of the Russian Federation, Ukraine, and United States, along with the new delegations, are led by white men. 

However, there will not be eleven chairs.  There will be sixty-six chairs representing sixty-six voices.  

And none of those sixty-six voices will have authority to bind their government, their institution, or their organization to a proposal without the government, institution, and organization discussing the proposal and then voting on the proposal, along with legislative bodies in some instances.  There will be required unanimity by members of the EU and by members of NATO.  Meaning, fifty-nine to zero to agree to any decision. 

Other than saying “good morning” or “good afternoon” what mandate, what unanimity can a representative or representatives meaningfully convey to the government of the Russian Federation? 

Next up may be a demand for representation from the 720-member Strasbourg, France-based European Parliament (EP) for a seat at the table. 

There is no unanimity among members of the EU and NATO about all issues relating to the government of Ukraine.  The longer duration of the Russian Federation-Ukraine War, the more fragility in support due primarily to cost to taxpayers and resistance from voters.  

For proof, look to the recent protests throughout EU countries and NATO countries.  The primary issues are domestic spending.  They are not protesting the government of the Russian Federation or the Russian Federation-Ukraine War.  They are not protesting to spend more money defending the government of Ukraine. 

In lockstep with pressure on EU members from the government of the Federal Republic of Germany to approve for the government of Ukraine what could approach US$700 billion in new taxpayer borrowing during the seven-year 2028-2034 EU budget is animosity and resentment from EU members towards EU administrative leadership, the government of Germany, and the government of Ukraine.  

Since 2022, EU taxpayers have incurred approaching US$1 trillion in costs related to the Russian Federation-Ukraine War.  The more pressure by the government of Germany to spend more to support the government of Ukraine, the EU debate will further imperil the trajectory for the government of Ukraine to obtain EU membership- and that vote will require unanimity rather than a possible qualified majority required for debt, funding, and borrowing. 

The government of Germany is framing EU borrowing as appropriate and necessary to defend the approximately twenty percent of the internationally-recognized territory of Ukraine occupied by the armed forces of the Russian Federation since 2014 and since 2022. 

Friedrich Merz, Chancellor of Germany (2025- ), maintains a three-men-in-a-room formula will not resolve the Russian Federation-Ukraine War.  He makes an exception for the one-man-in-the-room formula when he seeks to implement a financial cudgel to coerce the other twenty-six members of the EU to have their taxpayers blackmailed to fund the government of Ukraine not for 2026, not for 2027, but for seven years through 3034.  

And how does he think this strategy will impact voting for EU membership for the government of Ukraine after heads of state and heads of government have been blackmailed?  Likely Chancellor Merz will no longer be in office.

Administrative and political leadership in the EU (European Commission and European Council) do have a message:  Although the EU wants the government of Ukraine as a member, taxpayers in the EU will not bear alone the financial burden to defend the government of Ukraine.  Meaning, defending the government of Ukraine has limitations.  So much for solidarity.

And then there is the impact upon the conversations, dialogues, discussions, engagements, and negotiation process by the presence of Steven (“you are a humanitarian also” Mr. Putin) Witkoff, Assistant to the President, Senior Advisor, and Special Envoy (2025- ) of the Trump-Vance Administration, and Jared Kushner, a son-in-law of President Trump. 

Their future results can be inferred from their previous results.  Is Gaza in 2026 brought by Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff what the government of Ukraine will view as a success for its real estate? 

Negligence to ignore the self-promoted creative, direction, implementation, and production proprietorship by Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff for the Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict and Board of Peace, neither of which have achieved their marketed objectives. 

What is happening in Gaza?  The quality of life for its more than two million inhabitants which today occupy approximately thirty percent (and continuing to decrease) of the real estate they had prior to 7 October 2023, must be directly attributable to the legacy of Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff.  This was their diplomatic triumph.   

When looking at the Russian Federation-Ukraine War, the trajectory of the Kushner-Witkoff Gaza is the North Star. 

These are two white men, Jewish, from New York State, residing in the State of Florida, wealthy (one inherited, one self-made), have no diplomatic experience in the region, have no analytical historical perspective, and whose previous jointly-addressed architectural efforts included the Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict and Board of Peace, neither of which have achieved their marketed objectives. 

When Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff share about a desire by parties for “there to be a long peace after” important to reference how that is thus far working out for approximately two million inhabitants of in Gaza. 

For what was in 2022 was a one hundred and forty-four square mile internationally-recognized territory of Gaza with approximately two million inhabitants is in 2026 the same approximately two million inhabitants occupying approximately forty-three-square miles.  The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) control the remaining area while confining approximately two million inhabitants into a forty-three square mile concentration camp.  This result is the effort of Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff.  

For the government of Ukraine, for member countries of the European Union, for member countries of NATO, they should each be concerned by the potential outcomes devolving from the minds of Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff.

They each appreciate their political lifespan ends at 12:00 pm on Saturday, 20 January 2029.  Whatever has not transpired by that time or whatever transpires after that time becomes someone else’s problem.  As their attitudes relating to Gaza reinforce, their focus is the performance on opening night.  After that, they move on to the next opportunity. 

What makes Messrs. Kushner and Witkoff extraordinarily dangerous is their inability to appreciate the necessity to extract themselves from the Russian Federation-Ukraine War deliberations.  Their egos will not permit them to ask President Trump to remove them.

Important to remember: President Trump believes he has no ownership stake in the Russian Federation-Ukraine War.  The owners are the Bush-Cheney Administration (2001-2009), Obama-Biden Administration (2009-2017), and Biden-Harris Administration (2021-2025).  President Trump views his efforts bring the military component of the Russian Federation-Ukraine War to a conclusion or long-term cessation as a favor to his predecessors rather than an obligation. 

In 2022, then former President Trump shared his belief the armed forces of the Russian Federation would not have invaded further into the internationally-recognized territory of Ukraine had he occupied the Oval Office on 24 February 2022.  Upon returning to the Oval Office on 20 January 2025, President Trump has continued to repeat this assertion.  President Putin has agreed with this assertion. 

Last week, according to President Trump, President Putin confirmed again he would not have ordered the armed forces of the Russian Federation to invade further into the internationally-recognized territory of Ukraine had President Trump occupied the Oval Office on 24 February 2022. 

The paradox: Why would President Putin not have invaded further into the internationally-recognized territory of Ukraine had President Trump occupied the Oval Office on 24 February 2022, but now that President Trump has returned to the Oval Office refuse to stop, turn-around, and go home. 

If fear of and respect for President Trump would have deterred a decision, why has fear of and respect for President Trump not reversed a decision taken? 

President Xi and President Putin have described as having “no limits” their bilateral relationship.  The relationship President Putin has thus far with President Trump has limits. 

LINK TO COMPLETE ANALYSIS IN PDF FORMAT

Next
Next

Prime Minister Of Canada Could Be Star Of Fourth APEC Media Moment- But Potential Consequences To Upstaging POTUS In Advance Of December 2026 G20 In Florida.